A tour of Indy’s (local) high-end dining options
As an avid lover of food, one of my favorite parts of this business is when my gentleman escorts me to one of the best restaurants in Indianapolis. Whether you’re taking a vanilla date or a luxury companion, any restaurant on this list is sure to impress. I’ve loosely ordered these restaurants by how close they are to my heart.
Hinata is a Japanese Fine dining restaurant that offers a different fixed multi-course menu every month. The courses typically include a soup, some cooked dishes, some raw dishes, and a dessert. Don’t sleep on the wine and sake pairings. They are thoughtfully considered and elevate the dishes significantly. Hinata is open Wednesday-Saturday and only has two seatings an evening, so plan far in advance if you want to enjoy its spectacular food!
Vida is a new American focused on fresh ingredients and creative dishes. It offers three different dining options: a six-course fixed menu, a four-course choose-your-own adventure menu, and the option to order a la carte. There is a structured pairing for the fixed menu, but the excellent sommelier will also create pairings for your choices from the four-course menu. If you don’t manage to snag reservations, it’s still worth stopping by to see if there’s a spot open at the bar.
Bluebeard doesn’t offer a fixed multi-course menu, but the wide variety of farm-to-table dishes will invariably entice you to craft one for yourself. The bartenders at Bluebeard regularly create unique cocktails that are sure to please. Unfortunately, Bluebeard does not offer reservations. But they have a cozy fire pit out front if you have to wait to be seated.
Delicia is a Latin fusion restaurant. The service here is extremely warm and the food is delightful. I’m particularly a fan of their empanadas and the Fire ‘n’ Ice margarita. The restaurant is small and very popular, so reservations are highly encouraged.
St Elmo’s/Harry and Izzy’s
St. Elmo’s is an Indy classic. But its reputation extends far beyond Indiana’s borders. Of the restaurants on this list, it is certainly the most recognizable. St. Elmo’s is known for its legendary steaks and, my personal favorite, its horseradish-forward shrimp cocktail. While St. Elmo’s is about old-fashioned elegance, the sister restaurant, Harry and Izzy’s, has a more contemporary feel. If you’re hoping to eat at either restaurant during a conference, before a sporting event, or on the weekend, reservations are a must.
Nesso
Nesso is a contemporary Italian restaurant located in the beautiful Alexander Hotel. The restaurant is just as gorgeous as the hotel and the service is always prompt. The food is excellent, but it runs a bit heavy. Keep that in mind if you’re planning to be active after eating there.
Geraldine’s Supper Club and Lounge
Geraldine’s is modeled after the jazz clubs of yesteryear. The piano at the front of the restaurant often hosts a pianist tickling the ivories. And the food is just as good as the ambiance. Their steak is one of my favorites in the city and I find myself daydreaming about the crab cakes regularly. You’ll have to step outside of downtown to enjoy this gem, but it’s absolutely worth it!